Category: newsletter

  • Closing Remarks #50: Mourn AND Organize

    Whew! How is it July already?

    With travel to Boston, Barcelona, Marrakesh, and Lisbon, my June was eventful to say the least. I wanna start this edition of CR by thanking everyone who transported me and/or hosted me across the three continents. It was exhausting but illuminating and fun.

    Amidst all the trains, planes, and automobiles I was whizzing around (and sometimes experiencing terrifying turbulence) in, a few weeks ago, I walked over to my local library and picked up the 1954 book The Man Who Never Died: A Play about Joe Hill, with Notes on Joe Hill and His Times.*. For those who aren’t familiar, Joe Hill was a working class Swedish immigrant who came to the US to do menial day labor. He ended up quickly learning English, joining the radical union movement with the Industrial Workers of the World (IWW), and writing such iconic protest songs that he soon became the target of union-busting bosses across the country. One such boss — the owner of a copper mine — was so frustrated that he had Hill framed for murder and sentenced to die by firing squad. While activists and statesmen from Australia to D.C. attempted to stop the execution, Hill was eventually marched out to be killed amidst fervent protest. It is rumored that his final words to his comrades were, “Don’t mourn. Organize.”

    While the story of Hill was inspirational to me in many ways —- I mean who doesn’t want to write such bangers that people are moved to shut down factory floors? —I did, however, take a bit of umbrage at his words. The story of radical social change is full of many wins but far more failures. It has birth, maturation, and the sting of far too many deaths. We see hopefully beginnings but also (as we well know) many devastating ends.

    So it is that I remix Hill’s words to a phrase that is more fitting for the time we are in now, where we realize the importance of holding many emotions at once in order to do the critical inner work that will benefit our movements. To all of us in this moment, I say Mourn AND Organize; we can let the grief radicalize and embolden us even as the solidarity comforts us. We can absolutely do both!

    *Shouts out to rapper/director Boots Riley for mentioning this book here and reminding me to do more reading on him! Go see I Love Boosters, folks!

    Here are the links:

    1) Beloved Maryland Food Co-Op Shuttered

    Since the halcyon mid-1970s, the Bethesda Food Co-Op has offered organic food, household goods, and a base for people who not only wanted healthy food but also a deeper connection to their community. The store also served as a first workplace for generations of local teenagers. The store’s leadership made the difficult decision to close after years of struggling with competition from larger, corporate-owned chains. These issues were compounded by the loss of many loyal customers, federal employees who were DOGE’d out of their jobs early last year.

    2) Ohio Food Assistance Org Screeches to a Halt

    After “exhausting every option”, food assistance group Local Matters of Columbus has ceased operations. LM was known for its “Veggie Van,” which sold affordable produce, meal kits and other pantry staples, including flour and canned beans. The mobile market traveled throughout the area selling its products and offered online ordering, accepting SNAP and WIC benefits.

    They credited the sunset to “gradual impacts that put the organization in an untenable financial position,” including a “shift in philanthropic attitudes” and “the unexpected end of major ongoing funding.”

    3) UK Advocate for Working Parents Goes Out of Business

    Despite almost 5 decades of advocating for busy families and the care workers that support them, Working Families has succumbed to shifting political winds. The group provided legal advice to British families, guidance to employers, and pressure on policymakers to make workplaces more family-friendly. While charitable funding had not dried up for WF, they found that the national conversation around these g issues had shifted such that companies were less and less willing to work with them.

    Despite the blow, Working Families highlighted a number of achievements during its history, including supporting one in 10 UK parents to access free legal advice in 2024-25 and advocating for improvements in parental leave and carers’ rights, including Neonatal Care Leave Act 2023 and the Flexible Working Act 2023.

    4) Autism groups gets the job done

    South Carolina’s Champion Autism Network was formed in 2016 to make their community more friendly to individuals and families dealing with autism, and according to their leadership, they have achieved just that!

    According to their ED, “We have achieved our mission in wanting to create a community and an environment where people with autism can come out and play. And we’ve done exactly that.” The group’s initiatives are now being run by independent partners and former community members.

    I love a “mission accomplished” ending. They are the best!

    5) Crime Drops, Policy Shifts, Prisons Close, Society Wins!

    Between 1980 to 2013, under decades of “toughness on crime”, the American federal prison population ballooned from around 25,000 incarcerate people to almost 220,000. However, over the last almost-15 years, policy quietly shifted (and stayed shifting!) under numerous administrations, resulting in a plummeting number of inmates as well as shrinking staff head count, decaying infrastructure, and budget shortfalls. As such, the government has announced a list of prisons that they plan to shut down in the coming years.

    While the list is promising, going from a list to actually being emptied out and decommissioned is always a whole ordeal. Prisons are often large employers in the towns where they are located and the guard unions rarely give up without a fight. A lesser-regarded issue is the negative impact the move can sometimes have on inmates who often lose community support and resources when they move from one facility to another. So, y’know, we’ll see. But my fingers are crossed!

    6) Why Start at the End?

    Over the past six years through Solvable’s Department of Dismantling, we’ve been experimenting with the H2 horizon not only being about what an organization, community, or collective group might start doing, but also what they will no longer do. To intervene in ways that make a different future possible, “change is not just about building the new, but also actively unbuilding the current (hospicing, outgrowing, decommissioning, sunsetting, etc)”

    Welcome to the Ever/Was Collective! Really cool to see comrades popping up with timely closure support for the Canadian civil sector. Check out their hotline here!

    7) An Organizational Death Doula Guide: Letting Your Organization Die Gracefully

    More closures are coming, probably at a faster pace than our sector has ever felt. Can we prepare ourselves to sunset organizations in a way that feels transformative?

    In change management, people use the word “perturbation” when talking about a shock to the system. It’s a phrase that was carried over from harder sciences to the world of organizational psychology to help get at the idea of a disturbance that will have many intense consequences— some predictable, some not. What if we prepared for those we can predict? What if we held at the forefront of our work the larger community and mission served, above and beyond the function of our particular nonprofit or foundation?

    Behold! Yet another closure consultant emerges into the world. Dorothy Lee went from tackling existential questions as the ED of a small nonprofit to realizing that the sector needed to do endings better…and furthermore that she might be able to help! Check out Dorothy’s piece on Community-Centric Fundraising and then extend her some encouragement if you can.

    Yours in the end,
    Camille

  • Closing Remarks #49: Idle Fleet

    Graduates at the Siena College graduation

    I love borrowing concepts from other fields to help think and/or explain challenges in closure. One I love Is the idea of scuttling, a term from the maritime domain that refers to the process of deliberately drowning a ship or running it aground in order to address a specific problem. Ships get scuttled for several reasons, sometimes it is to make a quick escape in a dangerous situation, in other times it is to create an artificial reef or clear navigation channels for other vessels.

    So given my nerdy love and use of that nautical expression, I was excited to turn on the radio the other day and learn another one: fouling. Fouling occurs when a vessel sits idle for too long and begins to amass barnacles, algae,and other organisms on the ship’s body, which then causes it drag and damage. It turns out this sort of fouling is happening at this very moment to hundreds of ships that are currently just sitting and waiting in the Strait of Hormuz. Not only is there an effect to the body of the ships, there is also the psychological harm being inflicted on all the seamen sitting with uncertainty about whether and when they will get home as they wait for the resolution of a conflict they didn’t start and are powerless to influence.

    All this got me thinking about the long-term effects of uncertainty in the social sector. Of course, not every minute of the day can be capital-D Doing the work but I do wonder what might be deleterious effects having to pump the brakes to deal with financial and political crises. Among the questions swimming around in my mind are: How much wear and tear does it put on the battered body of a busy org and its overworked staff? Is there any way to do some amount of preventative anti-fouling (this is a real thing!)in anticipation of these times? How do continued periods of such fouling factor in to the calculation of any individual employee’s tenure or even the anticipated lifespan of an organization?

    Here are this week’s links:

    1) Priced out prison guards cause clinker closure

    After an initial 2019 decrease in the size of the penitentiary’s population, Asheville’s Craggy Correctional Center is now wrapping up all operations because the cost of living in this North Carolina town is pricing out current and potential prison guards. According to prison leadership, despite their best efforts they have only hired three guards in two years and most of its current staff commute to Craggy from further flung, less costly areas. As the 250 souls incarcerated at this location are transferred to other facilities throughout North Carolina, I sit here and wonder if the affordability crisis will somehow gift us a silver lining of decarceration…..

    2) Name mixup muddles a foundation’s wind down

    When The Dorot Foundation announced its ten-year spend down plan last month, phones began ringing off the hook…..at the anti-loneliness nonprofit also called Dorot (which means “generations” in Hebrew). Despite announcements from the foundation explicitly explaining that the two organizations had “no connection”, the confusion persisted, going so far as donors and funders of the non-foundation Dorot threatening to pull funding due to the perceived spend out!

    I spend a lot of time thinking about closure communications but cases of mistaken identity wasn’t on my BINGO card before reading this one…but it is now!

    3) Unfortunate faltering of AZ domestic violence hotline

    Despite growing rates of domestic violence in Arizona and a persistent need for support services, Phoenix’s SafeDVS was forced to abandon this vulnerable population and close its lifesaving phone line earlier this month. For about 15 years, this 24/7/365 call center operated a centralized referral system for all domestic violence shelters in Maricopa According to another local leader in this space, victims will now have to resort to calling shelters one by one to find a safe haven.

    4) Failed building bid bests Boston black business space

    For over a decade, Roxbury’s Black Market incubated new projects and hosted vendors and community events to stimulate the economy and foster self-empowerment in the Nubian Square area of this vibrant urban neighborhood. Unfortunately, after a deal to buy their building fell through, organizers declined to sign a lease extension with the building owner (itself a nonprofit) choosing instead to end the effort altogether.

    Organizers are now scrambling to vacate the premises, wrap up programs, and help current vendors secure new homes. Community advocates and planners say the episode highlights the broader challenge of turning cultural programming into sustained ownership in rapidly gentrifying neighborhoods.

    5) Quaker-based education on the ropes in New England

    Since 1961, Cambridge Friends School has provided elementary and middle school education rooted in the Quaker religious tradition to young people in the Cambridge area of Massachusetts. However, an email that went out earlier this month advised that the 2026/27 school year will be its last.

    Though no reason was provided, records reveal that enrollment at the school, which serves a high percentage of working class and students of color, has nosedived from 145 in 2023 to just 23 in the 2025/26 school year. School trustees says they will use the time after the final school year to explore options for continuing to promote Quaker education in the region.

    6) The grief of grantmaking

    “…grief is an inevitable part of life and is widely present in philanthropy and wealth distribution…a healthier philanthropic ecosystem would require us to get better at recognising it, naming it, and tending to it.”

    A great piece by the always-fantastic Louise Armstrong, who is the executive director at Thirty Percy Foundation and co-founder of UK closure firm The Decelerator.

    7) Passing the Torch: What It Means to Transition with Care

    “And while the headlines often focus on who’s leaving or what’s being lost, I’m starting to believe that change doesn’t have to feel like loss. It can also be an act of love if we approach them with care.”

    Sometimes I get so annoyed with LinkedIn that I wanna just delete my account and never go on there again and then other times, I come across ideas and people so invigorating that I remember why I am there. Miriam Messinger recently crossed my path on LinkedIn and reading this article that she co-wrote when she was at Interaction Institute for Social Change last year really made my day!

    THIS WEEK! THIS WEEK! THIS WEEK!

  • Closing Remarks #48: Making Good Use of “Nothing Decades”

    Vladimir Ilyich Lenin is credited to have once said something along the lines of, ‘”There are decades where nothing happens and weeks where decades happen.”

    If that doesn’t resonate with you right now, you aren’t paying attention (and I might be interested in blissfully sailing out to whatever island you are hiding out on). But if you are here and reading, your eyes are probably open and you are WIDE AWAKE and get it. Sometimes life and/or world events come at you fast. When you are lucky or prescient you are ready for it and nimble like a cat. However, other times you are comfortably working away and totally blindsided.

    While none of us can be omniscient, once you’ve lived a bit, it becomes clear that the only constant is change. Why then do we so often build organizations that seem to forget or ignore that? Part of what animates me here at The Wind Down is trying to get across the message that longevity and stability does not always correlate with impact.Sometimes we do need institutions that are strong like oaks, but other times we need structures that flow like water. How can our sturdy structures sustain during those “nothing decades” even as they help us stay alive to those weeks when decades bear down on us? My inbox is open if you’ve got the answer!

    In the meantime, here are the links:

    1) Michigan hunting and fishing group succumbs to the forces

    Just shy of its 90-year anniversary, Michigan United Conservation Clubs has announced they will be closing after failing to secure the full $100,000 it required for basic operating funds. For nearly 100 years, MUCC worked to defend hunting, fishing, trapping and conservation in the state. It consisted of individual members and affiliated clubs that paid dues to fund its work.According to its leadership, their shuttering will leave a void in the state’s conservation space.

    2) Rural Catholic college gives up the ghost

    Since 1946, Anna Maria College has provided a Catholic-centered education to undergrads and graduate students. While it initially opened as a women’s college, in 1973 it went co-ed. The school was best known for having the largest fire science program in the Northeastern area of the United States.

    However, the school’s mounting debt forced the Massachusetts Department of Higher Education to step in and push for the wind down.

    3) Canadian dairy cooperative dealt closure blow

    After being told that the plant was to be expanded, the 90+ employees of New Brunswick’s Agropur dairy plant along with the wider community are reeling at the news that their plant is scheduled to be shut down by 2028. According to reports, the end of this plant will affect not only the workers but the ability of New Brunswick to maintain its food security and independence.

    4) Doors (temporarily) swing shut at museum memorializing “Scotland’s Alcatraz”

    From 1883 to 2013, Peterhead Prison incarcerated thousands, and was also the site of several notable prison rebellions. Once decommissioned, it re-opened as a tourist attraction. However, new owners Cove Attractions have struggled to make it a big draw, so they are hitting pause to add more to the offering. They plan to open up more areas of the facility to the viewing public and also — because I guess they think it’s not in poor taste — an escape room option. Siiiiigh.

    5) Hampshire College and the Death of a Boomer Utopia

    “…In this unsettled moment, it makes sense that a place like Hampshire lost its relevance. And yet we might need its kind of unruly thinking now more than ever.”

    A NY Mag writer pays tribute to their alma mater and muses on what the closure of the very liberal liberal arts college (also based in Massachusetts) might portend for our society.

    6) “Nobody Told Me That Leaving Would Feel Like This

    “…in this sector, organizational failure and personal failure have become the same thing. When the organization struggles, we struggle. When it stumbles, we stumble. So we do what people do when their identity is on the line? We hold on. We fight. We downsize to a point of almost comedic inefficiency, keeping the lights on with a skeleton crew and a wing and a prayer, because closing means something we cannot stomach. It means we failed. Not the model, not the funding landscape, not the political conditions. Us. Closing gets read as a character flaw, a confession, proof that we were not enough. And so we choose almost anything, almost anything at all, rather than let it end.”

    Dr. Shawn Ginwright is a healing-centered leadership expert. In this piece, he shares how he is working with an ever-increasing number of impact leaders grappling with closures. If anyone needs to hear this today, let me be the first to say: you have done enough, and you are enough. Get some rest.

    UPCOMING EVENTS

  • Closing Remarks #47: Seeds Planted

    Last week, the fantastic artist and writer Molly Crabapple released her new book Here Where We Live Is Our Country. In this riveting tome, she recounts the story of the Jewish Labor Bund, a European socialist organization that ran from the late 1800s thru WWII. The Bund was committed to the full flowering of socialist solidarity alongside a rich Jewish cultural life and exchange, while keeping their feet firmly planted in the countries where they lived rather than embarking on a colonial project in some new far-flung place. The book is fantastic and you should get it if you can (it is on it’s 4th printing AS WE SPEAK!).

    However, I bring this up today not just to shill this amazing book, but to share something beautiful that Molly said about it. In this very thorough interview Molly gave on The Majority Report, she ended by saying,.“Even thought they had lost their country and their families and their milieu — even though they had lost that — they still planted the seeds for their own rediscovery.” A few days later, I saw Molly conversation with Naomi Klein, and in that chat she spoke of how she and other young creative, Jewish, anti-Zionist activists are not just living the legacy of The Bund;rather, she sees them as “not dinosaur fossils” but true comrades.

    What does our work mean if we think of our labors in arcs of centuries rather than fiscal quarters? How can we plant seeds along the way so future comrades can find us, speak with us, cultivate and harvest what we could only dream?

    Here are the links:

    1) Midwest hunger services group closes 80 locations

    For over 20 years, Ruby’s Pantry in (already-beleaguered!) Minnesota provided food and household necessities at 80 sites across the state. These items were distributed to people in need for low and no cost — with no questions asked. The groceries were primarily sourced using corporate donation of surplus and excess items. Rising fuel, insurance, truck repairs, and lease costs crippled the organization and forced the abrupt shutdown.

    2) Alaska’s only LGBTQ+ nonprofit health clinic to close

    Medicaid delays, a rise in rents, and and an increasingly transphobic political climate has forced Identity, Inc to announce that it will cease operations in mid-May. Founded in 1977 as the Alaskan Gay Community Center, Identity later merged with Full Spectrum Health clinic. Its main goal was to empower and advance healthcare for the LGBTQ+ community

    3) Anti-Palestine bullies force closure of Australian anti-abuse foundation

    In 2018, former Australian of the Year Grace Tame founded her charity to raise awareness for and agitate against abuse. As the survivor of childhood abuse, she formed the charity to help reshape national conversations around child safety. However, when Tame became outspoken against Israel’s genocide, she came under rising attacks, forcing the dissolution of her 5 year-old organization.

    4) 25% of US universities facing threat of shutdown

    It’s a crisis whose magnitude has been overshadowed by political and culture-war attacks on higher education and is propelled by the simple law of supply and demand after a long decline in the number of Americans who are going to college.

    “We have too many seats. We have too many classrooms,” Peter Stokes, a managing director at Huron, said of U.S. colleges and universities. “So over the coming five to 10 years, this shakeout is going to take place.”

    NPR news covers the crisis that is befalling so many of America’s centers of higher learning.

    5) Hundreds fired, hundreds more stranded by shelter shutter

    Sunstone Way operated several shelters across the Portland, Oregon area. However, an employee lawsuit and other unnamed business concerns lead to the abrupt announcement that is would be spinning down. In an area that already suffers from notable poverty and street homelessness, the closure also threatens put its 175 employees out of work.

    6) California River charity celebrates decades and departs

    For nearly 50 years, Brenda Adelman worked to raise awareness and advocate for the health of Northern California’s Russian River.through her organization The Russian River Watershed Protection Committee. At age 86, she is retiring, shutting down the organization, and sharing the legacy of her work with newer environmental groups.

    Adelman admits that the end of the organization had much to do with her team, stating, “I have to say that in our older years we have put most of our energy into writing comment letters, going to meetings and studying documents. Our board was not particularly interested in raising money and I was focused on the work and most of the time didn’t get paid.”

    7) Empowering Virginia Arts Org Draws Its Final Breath

    A lynch-pin of the local arts scene, Art 180 became known for its innovative programming and empowerment of Richmond youth through classes, workshops, paid internships and educational programs over the past 27 years. It also operates Atlas, a community arts hub and gallery and has functioned as a creative community space for local kids in need. Six years of “financial strain and shifts in funding” made it increasingly difficult to sustain the group. .

    8) The Last Days of the Longest UK Squat

    St Agnes Place in South London was the site of London’s longest ever running squat as well as the site of the London Rastafarian Community Centre and the Rasta Temple.. It was comprised of a row of 22 Victorian terrace houses and provided shelter for thousands of people between 1969 and 2007. This Huck Magazine article profiles a new book that chronicles the stirring words and images from the last years of the community.

    9) Arts Organizations Don’t Need to Last Forever

    “An organization that existed for fifteen years and changed lives and then ended with intention is a success story with a final chapter. The field needs people willing to write that chapter. It also needs the rest of us to stop treating it as an obituary and start treating it as what it actually is: evidence that the mission was real, the work was done, and the people involved had the courage to let go when it was time.”

    Excellent words by ​Emil J. Kang​ on his Substack, The Reprise. Emil is a cultural strategist and institutional advisor working at the intersection of the arts, philanthropy, education.

    Upcoming Events

  • Closing Remarks #46: Doc, Are We OK?

    MIlford Independent Cinema in Michigan

    I just returned from a beautiful retreat with a team I am supporting through a sunset process. At one point during one of our lively and delicious dinners, one of the team members asked me how their team compared to others I’ve worked with. This is a question I get frequently. I think of it as the “Doc, Am I OK?” question.

    If an organization or project seems like they are struggling, I will name the challenges but I never tell people they are abnormal or bad. I will tell them some of my general rules of thumb:

    • good endings tend to have long runways
    • healthy teams tend to have tearful, loving healthy endings — the process strengthens rather than weakens their bonds
    • every Wind Down is different and unique

    Not only is every organization distinct but every team member has their own feelings about what it means for it to end. As such, I discourage people from trying to rank themselves against any shutdown they’ve seen it the past or even anyone else on their team. While good wind downs are a team sport, they are also an inside job. If you feel good about it, then trust that feeling and share it. It just might be infectious!

    Here are the links:

    1) LGBTQ support organization enters managed wind down

    Formed in the 1980s, London-based Metro is one of the UK’s longest-running LGBTQ+ charities. The group has worked with anyone experiencing issues related to sexuality, identity, gender and diversity to provide support with sexual and reproductive health. More than 60 employees will lose their jobs in the sunset.

    2) Jobs program for disabled wraps up due to discrepancy

    For nearly 75 years, Sunshine Services has advocated for the well-being of adults and children with disabilities in Tennessee. Earlier this year, they announced that they would be ending their vocational training program Sunshine Industries. According to the group, the US Department of Labor reached out to advise them they were out of compliance on wages, and despite their efforts to rectify the issue it proved too late to save the program. They were, however, able to launch a $25,000 transition fund to support the 24 workers who lost their jobs in the affair.

    3) Enrollment plunges, a college falters

    Since the COVID pandemic, the student body at Massachusetts’s Laboure’ College of Healthcare has more than halved, plunging the school into financial peril and ultimately a closure. While the school is going out of business, its nursing program will live on at nearby Curry College. This marks at least the 4th university announcement of the year.

    4) Screen dims at beloved indie film theater

    After 54 years of lifting up Michigan-made independent cinema, the Milford Cinema in Oakland County has shuttered. Despite needing only $70,000 a year to operate, the group attributed the shutdown to financial issues and an overall shift in the industry.

    5) ‘Crisis’: The fallout from Trump’s surprise plan to close Kennedy Center

    “Orchestras are not like buildings. You can’t simply close them down for two years and expect that you can open them up again. They’re living organisms in a way.”

    The Washington Post outlines how the Wrecking Ball Regime continues to blaze its path of misery and destruction. This time with a surprise announcement that critical arts infrastructure is going to be taken offline for (as usual) no good reason.

    6) Closing a Business Responsibly: How to end well

    “A few weeks ago, I published this LinkedIn post announcing that my business partner and I were closing our B Corp certified agency, avery + brown, after 5.5 years. We were still profitable. We still had work coming in (and still do). But the market had shifted, the model wasn’t working the way it once had and, honestly, it just wasn’t fun anymore.”

    Thanks to everyone who tagged me on this great LinkedIn post nut Russ Avery, who reflects on shutting down a profitable B Corp agency. I love that he calls at the lack of fun as a reason. Fun matters!

    7) How Dissolving Your Nonprofit Can Strengthen The Sector

    “Nonprofit organizations need a two-way partnership rooted in transparency, where capacity building support, strategic planning, board development, executive coaching, and legal counsel all provide support to organizations throughout the life cycle and especially during difficult times. It is a partnership from the grant award through the end of the grant period.

    Leaders must be able to speak openly about their experiences. Without honest and transparent communication, more nonprofit organizations will struggle and possibly close. Funders who want to strengthen the field must also be willing to show up after the crisis, not just before it.”

    Traci Lester made the tough decision to sunset her organization, The Opportunity Agenda, last year. Despite a huge grant from Mackenzie Scott, the group still struggled to find sufficient operational funds. She is using her experience to argue for more support and transparency.

    8) Joe Macleod – Warmth of the Setting Sun: Belief and Identity in Digital Life (NEXT Conference)

    “Marketing is the only human made narrative structure where nobody cares about the end”

    A great little talk by my pal Joe Macleod, the king of ENDS.